Rating: 4.5 stars

Holly Black meets Lex Croucher in this contemporary fantasy about a love story to raise the dead.

At Demdike College of Witchcraft, Orlando is an outcast. Not just for being the only shapeshifter in a college of witches. Not just for being a really bad shapeshifter, with no control over their magic or when their body switches between male and female forms. But because their girlfriend Elizabeth died – and it was Lando’s fault.

Then charming new boy Bastian arrives with a proposition: he knows a spell that can raise Elizabeth from the dead. It’s dangerous but Lando will try anything. But as Lando’s attraction to Bastian grows, questions start to arise. Who is Bastian? What does he really want? And who will survive the resurrection spell?

For fans of V.E. Schwab and Rainbow Rowell, Emma Hinds’ Witchlore is a spellbinding contemporary fantasy where the passion is as real as the magic.

I received a digital copy of this book through the publisher on NetGalley for an honest review.

Witchlore was a fantastic book from start to finish that had me in a vice grip. From having a character like Lando, who struggles with the loss of their first love, I immediately found myself rooting for and hoping things would be alright in the end. The grief they experienced at witnessing Elizabeth’s death and how it’s covered in this book really can’t be described. Will say this book gets really dark with it, though, so for those who can’t handle that, I would highly suggest staying away. But personally, I find showing those moments of vulnerability and how a character overcomes their grief are needed in books for people who’ve personally gone through those moments in order to showcase the reality of grief and how it affects a person.

What I also enjoyed about this book was learning about the magic in this world, about the relationships between witches and shapeshifters. Something I personally felt like could’ve been elaborated a little more in the story, as a lot of this book was heavily focused on Lando and Bastian working together to bring Elizabeth back from the dead, I felt like there really wasn’t a lot of time spent fully explaining the relationship between witches and shapeshifters. I felt like what little bit I received was from the perspective of Lando and what they uncovered during their time getting ingredients for the resurrection spell, but not much outside of that. I also enjoyed the magic overall in this story, but would’ve loved to have seen more of it being used because again, I felt like that was something else that I personally felt like was lacking in the story too. I get why, because of who the main character is and what ends up being discovered plot-wise. I just personally wanted a little more myself since this is a fantasy story.

 I also found the truth surrounding the resurrection spell enjoyable. It was a twist that I was able to connect with early on in the story, but I felt it was necessary to allow both Lando and Bastian to move on from the grief and loss they experienced from losing the people they loved. I especially enjoyed seeing Lando’s different shifts throughout while getting the ingredients to perform the spell and learning more about their past that had been hidden from them.

If there’s anything I didn’t particularly enjoy with Witchlore, it’s how those who don’t fit in get treated in their world. This is seen by how Lando gets treated as a shapeshifter, unable to control their magic and bullied because of it. And Lando is treated very terribly by their peers, to the point of having no one at college that they considered a friend until Bastian arrives and changes everything. It also isn’t ever dealt with either, except for when Lando stands up for themselves, because whenever Bastian does, he ends up getting into more trouble than the person who’s bullying Lando.

Overall, though, I enjoyed reading Witchlore as it had my attention from start to finish. Had a unique set of characters set in an interesting world that I couldn’t get enough of, and I was sad when I finished reading this book because of how much I enjoyed reading their story. Highly recommend for those who want to read a story with magic and romance between two unique characters. Witchlore was published on October 14, 2025, for those interested in giving this book a read.