
Rating: 3.5 stars
Sadie Revelare has always believed that the curse of four heartbreaks that accompanies her magic would be worth the price. But when her grandmother is diagnosed with cancer with only weeks to live, and her first heartbreak, Jake McNealy, returns to town after a decade, her carefully structured life begins to unravel.
With the news of their grandmother’s impending death, Sadie’s estranged twin brother Seth returns to town, bringing with him deeply buried family secrets that threaten to tear Sadie’s world apart. Their grandmother has been the backbone of the family for generations, and with her death, Sadie isn’t sure she’ll have the strength to keep the family, and her magic, together.
As feelings for Jake begin to rekindle, and her grandmother growing sicker by the day, Sadie faces the last of her heartbreaks, and she has to decide: is love more important than magic?
This book was an enjoyable read for me from start to finish. What I enjoyed about reading The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic was seeing more of Sadie’s small-town life and the magic in the story, along with getting to know her family and friends. I enjoyed seeing her interactions with her family members, best friend, and Jake as she develops throughout the story. The reason I enjoyed these interactions so much is because you can see how much all these characters care about each other.
The love everyone has for each other is apparent whenever Sadie finds out her grandmother is sick and her aunts all come into town during her final days to spend time with her. As someone who’s lost their grandmother this year herself, this part of The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic was one of the most difficult parts of the story for me to get through, especially when she does pass, because I found myself getting emotional as I was reading. I knew it was coming, but seeing how everyone in town paid their respects to her was so touching. It made me appreciate this story even more and want to continue reading to see how Sadie handles everything without having her grandmother there.
When it comes to the magic in this book, what I enjoyed about it was finding out how magic works in the Revelare family. For Sadie, most of her magic was used through her cooking and whenever she would go out into the garden and grow plants. You even get to see these recipes in the book, as they are at the end of each chapter, which I found to be very cool to include, even though I’m not much of a cook myself. As for the rest of the family, you find out how their magic works as you are introduced to the characters in the story. The exception being Seth, who didn’t share anything about his magic in this book until later in the story, when Sadie and he were trying to figure out how to break the curse their grandmother told them about before she passed.
Speaking of the curse, that’s one of the biggest criticisms with The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic I have is how the author shares the story of the curse. She makes it seem like the curse that could potentially hurt Sadie or Seth isn’t that big a deal, but the story behind it, to me, feels overall really serious. The cause of the curse itself is very traumatic to begin with, but it gets glossed over in this book as if it’s not at all a serious thing. But to me, talking about someone being assaulted is a very serious thing. And then finding out you are conceived as a result of that assault too is definitely something that should seriously be talked about, but it never does here. I also didn’t like with the curse that their grandmother had kept it a secret from them until she was dying. Also, she didn’t give them any real information about it that could be helpful to combat it until her death. I understood that she couldn’t really help them with dealing with it since it was a problem they had to deal with once she was gone, but I feel like she could’ve told them about this sooner so they could’ve been trying to figure out which of them was impacted by it and tried to figure out how to fix it before it was too late.
Along with the curse, the author tends to gloss over serious topics she brings up that could be seen as themes in this book. The main character loses her grandmother in this story, and while Sadie does have moments where she doesn’t deal with her grief well, most of the time she acts like her normal self afterward. Of course, when it comes to what she does to figure out how to stop the curse that could hurt her brother, Sadie almost makes a decision she can’t take back, but it doesn’t really get talked about with the other characters either. The only ones who know about it are Seth, her best friend, and Jake. And afterwards, they make a fuss at her about it and tell her she needs counseling for her grandmother’s death but they don’t tell the rest of the family what she did. Both her best friend and Seth also have different health issues, and you discover her best friend is getting help for hers, but this book tends to gloss over Seth’s issues even when there are conversations around him getting help for his. It especially bothers me because his health issues are a central plot point of the story regarding the curse, but the story focuses so much on Sadie stopping the curse and using her magic to do so that talking about his mental health doesn’t happen, other than saying he needs to get help, and that’s it. And this happens with every serious issue brought into the book, which bothered me enough that I can’t rank this book higher than I have, no matter how much I might’ve enjoyed reading The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic.
I would also say that, while I enjoyed the development of Jake and Sadie’s relationship when this book started, the direction it went was predictable to me. I felt like them starting off as friends was great because, yes, I could see how much they both still cared about each other. However, I felt like they were better off as friends to me. But that’s because I also wanted to see how the two of them had originally fallen in love with each other in the past so I could understand how they were still attracted to each other in the present. Because I quite frankly didn’t understand them still having feelings for each other, taking the issues that were causing them originally not to be together when Jake comes back to town out of the equation aside. Yes, I knew how much Sadie cared about Jake, and you could see how much he loved her too, but I still, even now, only picture them as friends, even if that’s not how things turned out.
But overall, I enjoyed reading The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic because I enjoyed the story I was reading within its pages and learning more about its characters, the town, and the magic Sadie and the rest of her family inherited. This book also pulled me in emotionally, which made me want to read it further to see what would happen next. It wasn’t a perfect read by any stretch of the imagination because there were aspects of the curse that bothered me, the way the author talks about serious topics in this book bothered me, and I found the direction Jake and Sadie’s relationship went in predictable. However, I still enjoyed it despite these aspects of the story and can’t wait to read The Secret Society of Second Chance Magic in the future, which I’ve heard is supposed to be a sequel to The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic because it takes place in the same town as this book. For those who like to read fantasy that takes place in a small-town setting with a little bit of romance, I highly recommend reading this book, as I think you’ll enjoy it. However, if you like to read books that don’t gloss over serious issues, this book might not be the read for you.







