Rating: 4 stars
An aspiring young actor must find her place at a cutthroat arts boarding school in this gothic YA debut for fans of Ace of Spades and If We Were Villains.
Violet Costantino knows she is already on thin ice this school year: her scholarship has taken a significant hit due to her panic attack during her final performance in acting class last semester—which simultaneously shattered her dreams of becoming a leading lady. This year, she is determined to keep her head down and just get through unscathed. But the school seems to have other plans for Violet: to her extreme foreboding, she is cast as one of the leads in the annual Halloween play. What’s worse, the beautiful, infuriatingly talented Frankie Lin and Violet’s ex-crush, Hunter Kinsley, are both cast as her love interests. Despite her initial reluctance, Violet is drawn in by the glamor of the Dark Cove Theatre Society, and she cautiously starts believing that maybe she is cut out for this after all. But lurking in the shadows of Violet’s fragile self-confidence is the rumor of the Society curse, which is said to cause one cast member to drop out before opening night every year, mysteriously and without reason.
In this captivating YA debut, The Dark Cove Theatre Society illustrates both the intoxicating and insidious nature of success and the price we are often forced to pay for it. Passages of found text—glimpses of the school’s handbook, secret letters, and other peeks into life at the Academy—seamlessly woven into the plot will immerse readers even further into the lush, magnetic world of Dark Cove.
I received a digital copy of this book through the publisher on NetGalley for an honest review.
The Dark Cove Theatre Society was a wonderful read that I enjoyed from start to finish. What I enjoyed from reading this book was seeing Violet’s character development from the beginning of being cast in the play to the night of the performance. As a character struggling with anxiety, the last thing Violet wanted to do was star in her school’s annual Halloween play. Nonetheless, be cast as one of the leads in the play. All she wanted to do when returning to school was put her head down and make sure to get through the school year, writing plays instead of acting in them. But seeing her character gain confidence in her abilities in acting was marvelous, and I found myself feeling happy for her growth in this book. Felt like there were a lot of themes covered in this book that Sierra Riley brought into the story that teenagers today could relate to, as some of these teenagers were dealing with.
What I also enjoyed about reading The Dark Cove Theatre Society is the overall setting of the school. I felt like my imagination of this academy went wild while I was reading this book, and I just wanted to learn more about it. It felt like the perfect backdrop for everything that happened in this book, and I was excited to learn more about the classes Violet and her peers were taking. Especially when Violet tried out for the play and found out about the curse every year that causes a student to leave the school before opening night of the play. What also helped with my interest in this school was the way Riley would use newspaper articles from the school from the past that talked about the school, secret letters, etc. It felt like the perfect spooky read to me, with the way the school was set up, from the setting of the book to the curse that affects one of the students in the play every year. Also, I enjoyed learning theatre terminology throughout the book since I’ve never taken any acting classes in school.
If there’s anything with The Dark Cove Theatre Society I didn’t particularly enjoy, it would be how most of the aspects of the story I was looking forward to seeing happened off the page. For example, when you find out the truth surrounding the curse, it doesn’t come as too much of a surprise to me because it seemed like that’s where the story was leading to. But when it comes to how those responsible for it get punished, the reader doesn’t get to see that unfold. You just heard about it through Violet being told that it happened instead of her witnessing it taking place. The same thing happens with the play, too. Yes, you get to see all of Violet’s character growth from the beginning of the story, when she was initially still reeling from what happened the previous school year, to her gaining confidence in herself as the school year goes on, during the practice of the play. But I was also expecting to get to see a little bit of the performance, too, just because of how central it was to the plot of this book. These are the parts of the story that I feel like should’ve been worked on and made the story all the more interesting to read.
I also wasn’t too fond of the romance in this book too just because I feel like there wasn’t enough character development for all of the characters in this book for the romance that does happen to really catch my attention. The only character who gets any development in this story is Violet, but everyone else in this book, from start to finish, acts pretty much the same. Which I don’t necessarily mind because her best friend, Kay, is one of my favorite characters in this book, along with the person who ends up catching Violet’s attention, Fran. All the other characters in this story, though, besides the ones I’ve mentioned, were pretty boring or mean and didn’t add anything to the story for me to care enough about what happened to them. Even the teachers at this academy weren’t great either.
As a whole, though, I enjoyed reading The Dark Cove Theatre Society as I enjoyed seeing Violet’s character development and getting to visit this academy. This book felt like the perfect read at this time of year, and I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys reading young adult, dark academia books. The Dark Cove Theatre Society was published on October 7, 2025, for those interested in giving this book a read.
Rainy Day's Books, Video Games and Other Writings 