Rating: 3 stars
Walter Simmering is searching for love and purpose in a city he doesn’t realize is fading away—San Francisco in 1993, at the height of the AIDS epidemic and the dawn of the tech revolution. Out of college, out of the closet, and transplanted from the Midwest, Walter is irresistibly drawn from his shell when he meets Cary Menuhin and Sasha Stravinsky, a dynamic couple who live blithely beyond the boundaries of gender and sexuality. Witty and ultra-stylish, Cary and Sasha seem to have stepped straight out of a sultry film noir, captivating Walter through a shared obsession with cinema and Hollywood’s golden age.
As the three embark on adventures across the city, filled with joie de vivre, their lively friendship evolves in unexpected ways. When Walter befriends Lawrence, a filmmaker and former child actor living with HIV, they pursue a film project of their own, with hilarious and tragic results.
Midnight at the Cinema Palace is a vibrant and nostalgic exploration of young souls discovering themselves amidst the backdrop of a disappearing city. Christopher Tradowsky’s astonishing debut captures the essence of ’90s queer culture and the complex lives of friends seeking an aesthetically beautiful and fulfilling way of life.
I received a digital copy of this book through the publisher on NetGalley for an honest review.
Midnight at the Cinema Palace was an interesting read, particularly in its exploration of the characters’ relationships and the discussions that involved sexuality. I particularly enjoyed seeing Walter’s relationships with Cary and Sasha, as well as his friendships with Jeff, Fiona, Kelly, and Lawrence. I feel that all these characters made this book interesting for me to read, as they each brought Walter out of his introverted shell and made him see the world he lived in from a different perspective. As I had never read a story that deeply explored the relationship between a throuple, I was fascinated to see how Walter, Cary, and Sasha interacted with each other and how their sexuality influenced their interactions. With regards to Walter’s friendships, it was interesting to see how he interacted with all of his friends in comparison to how he acted when he was with Cary and Sasha.
What I also enjoyed about this book is how descriptive Christopher Tradowsky’s writing is when it comes to describing San Francisco and the life Walter lives. While at times the story felt too descriptive, so that I felt overwhelmed in trying to imagine this city, I also felt like this book was a love letter to San Francisco and to those who live there. It was also interesting to read about this time to me, as 1993 is the year I was born. So it was interesting to read about this time from the perspective of an adult living through this time since I didn’t personally get to experience what Walter and this cast of characters were going through.
I also enjoyed Midnight at the Cinema Palace as there were segments of the screenplay Walter and Cary were working on together included in some of the chapters. I found it interesting to be given the screenplay they were working on together, as I was reading about their relationship, as I was able to see how they worked together creatively.
If there’s anything with this book, I didn’t particularly enjoy it was the plot. Or lack thereof, because I was expecting it to be a little different from what it was. In the synopsis of the book, the AIDS epidemic was mentioned, but as a reader, the AIDS epidemic isn’t a huge part of the plot in the story. The main story here is with regard to Walter’s relationship with Cary and Sasha. Which I didn’t necessarily mind as I like them as characters and was interested to see how things would transpire with them. My problem with this being the plot is that I didn’t truly feel like the story went anywhere here until Walter met them. So the beginning of the book was very slow-moving to me until they came into the picture.
But even once they all meet, I still feel like the plot wasn’t all that much either. Mostly because a majority of their interactions with each other involved going out partying together, and Walter getting drunk. Which, to me, felt like a filler in the story, as I feel like most of those times out together didn’t need to be written about. I feel like the book didn’t pick up plot-wise until halfway through, which isn’t good because people are more likely to have already decided if they’ll continue reading the book by that point.
As a whole, though, what made Midnight at the Cinema Palace a good read for me was the characters and seeing the world of San Francisco they live in. Just be prepared to be disappointed if you’re looking to read a book with a fast-moving plot, as this book doesn’t have one, even though it was still enjoyable to read. For those interested in reading Midnight at the Cinema Palace, it was published on June 10, 2025, so it is now available for you to read.








