Rating: 4 stars
As spiritualism reaches its fevered pitch at the dawn of the 20th century, a Scottish girl crosses the veil to unlock a powerful connection within an infamous asylum in this thrillingly atmospheric, exquisitely evocative exploration of feminine rage and agency for readers of Sarah Penner, Alice Hoffman, and Hester Fox.
Leaving behind a quiet life of simple comforts, Nairna Liath traverses the Scottish countryside with her charlatan father, Tavish. From remote cottages to rural fairs, the duo scrapes by on paltry coins as Tavish orchestrates “encounters” with the departed, while Nairna interprets tarot cards for those willing to pay for what they wish to hear.
But beyond her father’s trickery, Nairna possesses a genuine gift for communicating with the spirit world, one that could get an impoverished country girl branded a witch. A talent inherited from her grandmother, Lottie Liath, widow of a Welsh coalminer, whose story of imprisonment and exploitation in a notorious asylum is calling out to Nairna from four decades past—a warning to break free from the manipulations, greed, and betrayals of others.
What do the cards hold for Nairna’s future?
Rescued from homelessness by a well-connected stranger, Nairna is whisked into a new life among Edinburgh’s elite Spiritualist circle, including visiting American star Dorothy Kellings. Researchers, doctors, psychics, and thrill-seekers clamor for the rising young medium. But after a séance with blood-chilling results, a shocking scandal ensues, and Nairna flees to a secluded community near Boston, where she assumes a new Nora Grey.
But Nora can’t stay hidden when Dorothy Kellings offers her the chance to face all comers and silence skeptics at a spectacular séance at Boston’s Old South Meeting Hall, where Nora will come face to face at last with her spiritual the courageous Lottie Liath, whose heart-wrenching story and profound messages are indelibly tied to Nora’s destiny.
I received a digital copy of this book through the publisher on NetGalley for an honest review.
The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is a fantastical historical fiction novel that focuses on the history of spiritualism. This is explored through the perspectives of Nairna (also known as Nora Grey) and her grandmother, Lottie, who both unexpectedly discover their spiritual abilities. I enjoyed reading the perspectives of both women on what was happening in their lives and how they each confronted their newly discovered abilities, as I found learning about these spiritual experiences to be very interesting.
While both these women lived in different times, what connected them (besides the obvious) was their disdain for the circumstances they found themselves in when it came to utilizing their talents. How others manipulated both of them for personal gain, one manipulated in the name of science and research, and the other manipulated so that others could gain notoriety and be set up for life. It’s no wonder this book is full of feminine rage because both women had several people trying to use them for their gain without caring how Nairna and Lottie felt about it. And I found myself feeling empathetic towards both women as a result as I read their stories, hoping for the best for them.
What I also enjoyed about The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey was in the beginning of each chapter, the articles pertaining to the events that take place in the story. They felt like a good sneak peek into what I could expect to happen in their following chapters and helped me to piece everything that was to happen together.
I also enjoyed the different relationships that occurred throughout the story, mostly with regard to Lottie’s relationships to the women in charge of the asylum she was sentenced to stay in, and Nairna’s complicated relationship with her father, Tavish. I felt like the women in the asylum, Lottie finds herself forced to stay in, genuinely cared about her well-being, and wanted to do right by her, but unfortunately, didn’t have too much power when it came to stopping the doctors’ “experiments.” As for Nairna and her father Tavish, while I didn’t like Tavish in the beginning of The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey because of what he had Nairna help him do to survive in their world, once Nairna makes a name for herself as Nora and Lottie begins to make her appearances, I found myself feeling for him in this book. This is mostly due to him not getting the chance to know his mother all his life, and him having to find out the truth behind why that was the case through Nairna’s abilities. I felt like it was a good way for this book to show generational trauma, which made him a more sympathetic character in the story.
One of the issues I have with The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey, though, is that while I enjoyed the story, it also felt too predictable. I feel this way because it was pretty obvious once you know who Lottie is in relation to Nairna that things don’t work out for her. Especially knowing already that Tavish didn’t know either of his parents, it became clear that things weren’t going to change just because Nairna and Lottie were able to see each other, even though they lived in different times. Nairna’s story is also predictable to me because I knew already she was continuing to do these seances because of wanting to uncover the full story of what happened to her grandmother once she realized that’s who she was seeing. She also makes it clear how she feels about participating in these seances early on, so it was no surprise to me that once she finds out what she does that she decides to no longer participate in them.
I was also disappointed with the magical aspects in this book. I feel like this aspect of the story disappointed me because, as the reader, I was given insight into how these seances were made possible, and I feel like that ruined a little of the magic for me. It also felt more like science than magic to me, especially because of the way it’s explained and the way the doctors use Lottie for their experiments.
As a whole, The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist NoraGrey was an enjoyable read for me. I enjoyed learning more about spiritualism through Nairna and Lottie’s perspectives, seeing the theme of feminine rage throughout, and enjoying the articles at the beginning of each chapter as they gave me a sneak peek of what was to come. And I recommend this book to others reading this post who enjoy reading historical fiction that focuses on spiritualism, and those who enjoy reading books that discuss feminine rage. The Entirely True Story of the Fantastical Mesmerist Nora Grey is set to release on July 29, 2025 for those interested in giving this fantastic book a read.
Rainy Day's Books, Video Games and Other Writings 