Rating: 4 stars

Maggie is an unapologetically grumpy forty-eight-year-old hermit. But when her college-aged son makes her a deal―he’ll be more social if she does the same―she can’t refuse. She joins a new online gaming guild led by a friendly healer named Otter. So that nobody gets the wrong idea, she calls herself Bogwitch.

Otter is Aiden, a fifty-year-old optimist using the guild as an emotional outlet from his family drama caring for his aging mother while his brother plays house with Aiden’s ex-fiancée.

Bogwitch and Otter become fast virtual friends, but there’s a catch. Bogwitch thinks Otter is a college student. Otter assumes Bogwitch is an octogenarian.

When they finally meet face to face―after a rocky, shocking start―the unlikely pair of sunshine and stormy personalities grow tentatively closer. But Maggie’s previous relationships have left her bitter, and Aiden’s got a complicated past of his own. Everything’s easier online. Can they make it work in real life?

After the series I’ve been reading, Role Playing was the perfect read for me to pick up. It featured two protagonists I felt I could relate to on a personal level, had romance, and was overall a fantastic read. What I find relatable about both these protagonists in this book is how big of introverts they are and their love for online gaming. As an introvert myself, it was nice seeing two people connect through online gaming and for that to help spark into a romantic relationship.

What I also enjoyed when reading this book was how the author went into serious topics, such as sexuality. We quickly find out why both these characters have issues in relationships and discover with Aiden that he’s not only bisexual but demisexual as well. And it was nice to see LGBTQ representation in this book, especially in a way I felt like I could relate to. As someone myself who’s only been in relationships with people who I could connect to on an emotional level, it was nice to read about a character with similar experiences. I also love that this was used as a learning opportunity for characters in the story. It not only showed the characters learning but felt to me like a good point for anyone reading this book that didn’t know what demisexual is to go look it up and find out for themselves and I really loved seeing that in this book.   

What I also liked about Role Playing was that the two protagonists in the story, Maggie and Aiden, were both older characters. It isn’t very often that I’ve read romance books that featured older characters. So it was nice seeing two older people fall in love with each other and was eager to find out how their relationship would continue to grow.

If I had to choose anything to criticize with this book it would have to be Aiden’s family. From the beginning, I wasn’t all that fond of them anyway. But as the book went on and they repeatedly made him out to be a bad person no matter what he did, I found myself disliking them more and more. I especially disliked his mother and Sheryl because they both treated him terribly. But when the truth comes out as to why they act the way they do towards him, I find myself disliking them both even more and am happy to see Maggie calling them both out on their shit in this book because they both deserved it. I wasn’t too fond of Aiden’s brother either, but I felt like out of the members of the family, he was more open to accepting Aiden so that made him slightly better to me.

Another criticism I have for this book was the romance itself. While this book felt like a cozy read to me and I enjoyed that aspect of it, I felt like the romance between Maggie and Aiden moved almost too slowly. I felt like I kept waiting for it to pick up the pace, but it never did. I also felt like there just wasn’t enough of it either because I don’t feel like I truly saw their relationship fully develop throughout the story. Even with the epilogue, I felt like I didn’t fully get to see their relationship and see what the two of them being together was like. Yes, I like both of their characters and they went through quite a bit together throughout the story because of Aiden’s family, but I just felt like there was something missing with their romance that as a reader I didn’t see.

However, I overall enjoyed reading Role Playing. It was a cozy read, with introverted protagonists I could relate to despite their age difference to me. I really enjoyed the representation of a bisexual and demisexual character and I liked that the romance in this story was between two older characters as that’s something I haven’t seen very often in romance books. I highly recommend this romance story to any introvert who enjoys video games as much as I do, anyone in the LGBTQ community and anyone who’d enjoy reading a romance between two older characters.